Skip to main content

When Our Whys Are Met with Silence, We Rest...

Why do the nations rage? Why do the peoples plot in vain?  These questions posed in Psalm 2:1 echo the questions many of us have been asking...often through tears. Why? Why did so many die at Sandy Hook Elementary?  Why did so many die in Aurora? Why did so many die at Virginia Tech? Why did so many die in Manhattan, in Washing DC and in the field in Pennsylvania? Why did so many die at Columbine High School? Why did so many die in Oklahoma City?  Why did so many die at Auschwitz? Why do so many die in what is supposed to be the protective and nurturing safety of the womb?  Why do the nations rage?  Why do the peoples plot in vain?

The psalmist rivets to our hearts the reality we live in. Sinners rage and plot against the purposes of God.

He has created the universe and determined to sprinkle throughout His world image-bearers. These image-bearers proclaim, by their very existence, that there is a King who rules all that is and He is YHWH. (Romans 1)

Everyone everywhere either submits to the rule of this King or they push against it; they rage and plot.

When we sin, we plot against His rule. Our hearts rage against Him. The ultimate manifestation of this plotting and raging is the taking of human life; defacing and destroying His image-bearers. It is evil and the goal of Satan himself (Revelation 12).


As we watch and listen to the grieving parents, take in more details of the murderous rampage in Newtown, we legitimately ask the same questions the psalmist asks in Psalm 2.  Why?  Why!?!

And when we ask why; we will seek answers in one of two ways, as plotters and those enraged, or as submissive servants.

The plotters and enraged ask the legitimate "Why?" question in unbelief. They choose not to attribute chaos and tragedy to His rule.  They choose to reject His reign and His revelation of Himself to all peoples.  They might say: "If Jesus is King, then He should have stopped this. If King Jesus rules, He should have intervened.  The King must have abdicated His throne. Because, if He was ruling, these tragedies would not have happened." Be warned, fellow-strugglers, if these are your words, they are indictments against the One True King and they come from hearts that rage and plot against Him.

Submissive servants ask the legitimate "Why?" question steeped in the faith-work of seeing the revelation of Himself.  He is King. He was sitting on His throne and actively ruling when on Friday, December 14th, 2012 Adam Lanza killed so many.  He was sitting on His throne and actively ruling when on Friday, July 20, 2012 James Holmes shot so many in Aurora. He was sitting on His throne and actively ruling when on Monday, April 16, 2007 Seung-Hui Cho murdered Virginia Tech students. Lanza, Holmes, Cho and millions of others raged against the rule of the King, plotted against the reign of King Jesus.Those who seek to be submissive servants hurry to verse 6 and following.  By faith they see that God has set His Son on His holy hill.  He possesses the nations, even the raging ones; He possesses everything and everyone.

And the plotters and the enraged are warned to be wise; they are called to turn their rage into a submissive kiss.  Those who refuse will be broken, dashed to pieces by King Jesus.  Those who submit will find their only refuge in Him.

Evil is evil precisely because our King reigns! The only way to begin to process evil is in the context of the only Good, Wise and Perfect King who rules every molecule and every movement at every moment. There is no other basis to recognize evil as evil.

Evil exists and this is not the way it is supposed to be. We weep and and our hearts ache.  So many have had their lives upended by so much evil. Christians are those who are duty-bound to genuinely grieve. We grieve for the inconsolable survivors. But we also grieve because we are reminded that sin, in all of its manifestations, cost our Triune God an incalculable price. The Father broke the Son, He dashed Him to pieces. The King not only rules and reigns over the raging, plotting chaos we see; He subjected Himself to it. In His death, resurrection and ascension and with a deafening command He has answered all evil everywhere once and for all.  Christmas time splashes this truth all over us and it is our only hope.

Fellow saved sinners, by God's grace, we may never choose to inflict such horrific suffering as Lanza, Holmes or Cho. But may we never submit to the lie that the real problem is found outside of us. We must recognize our treasonous ways, the ways we plot and rage against our King in our sin, confess it and then return submissively to Him

The hope and refuge offered to the raging nations and the plotting peoples in Psalm 2:10-12 is the hope and refuge found only in our King who presently reigns. In the face of such unspeakable acts, we can only rest in Him; the One who has been set on Zion, His holy hill.

We are speaking God's Word after Him when we ask why; Why? Why do the nations rage? Why do the peoples plot in vain? We must ask the question. But let's not settle there.  Let's keep moving, like Psalm 2 instructs us and then, with tear-drenched eyes and heavy but open hearts look heavenward and beg for the quick return of our King who will, one day, set all things right.

[Based on the sermon on Psalm 2 preached at Grace Community Presbyterian Church, Fort Worth, TX on December 16th, 2012.]


Popular posts from this blog

Getting the Most from Reading your Bible

 The start of the new year often means the start of a new Bible reading plan. For most of us, we start strong, fight through the "descendants" and difficult names. The familiarity of Exodus (thanks to  Cecil B. DeMille ) puts some winds in our reading sails.  Then we hit the rough waters of Leviticus. You get the idea... God reveals Himself to us in His Word. We want to see Him in His Triune glory there. Fighting against the difficulty of reading regularly, consistently, and prayerfully is one of the most important battles we face every day that God gives us.  Below, I am recommending three resources that may help you, not just stick with your Bible reading, but love God's Word more, even the difficult parts. My prayer is that one or two or all three of these resources will help you fight and win the battle so you can consistently read God's Word and God will consistently bless you through your personal Bible reading.  This is not a countdown, from best to least best.

Suffering--Book Brief

Paul Tripp is a faithful counselor and has served me and many of you through his conferences, books, video series, newsletters and booklets. He has written on the transition to middle age, love, sex, and money, raising teens and many other subjects.  If you are not familiar with him or his writing, I highly recommend him. His latest book, Suffering , is the best thing he has written. There are multiple contact points any reader will have with this book because suffering is universal. We all experience it. We can’t escape it. Tripp, through his decade's long association with the Christian Counseling and Education Foundation (CCEF) has counseled hundreds of sufferers. You will hear many of their stories in this book. More importantly, you will hear how a skilled biblical counselor helps the sufferer frame her experience in such a way that the truths of the Bible connect to the experience of the sufferer. The chapters “The Awareness Trap”, The Fear Trap”, “The En

David Powlison (1949-2019)

David Powlison died around 11am on Friday, June 7th, 2019. I wrote this about him a couple of years ago: He taught some of my counseling classes at WTS and is the Executive Director of CCEF. His ability to pastor the human heart and his relentless pursuit of the glory of Christ was on display in the classes he taught. We would often begin classes by singing a hymn together and Dr. Powlison would pull a nugget of truth from the hymn and riff for a few minutes. It was always encouraging to our faith. I will forever be grateful to Dr. Powlison and his wife Nan for how kind they were to me and my young family. He has left a treasure for us in what he has published. Without reservation, I recommend everything below: The Journal of Biblical Counseling . You can subscribe to the digital copy or a hard copy. He was the editor and past copies are available. Seeing with New Eyes . This is a "vision shaping book" that makes the case that the Bible is sufficient for all we e